You decided that Chucks must pay for betraying you.
You invited Collins, Isaac, Mitchell, Ken, and Martians (those are your thrusted friends now) to conspire against Chucks. You ask for their opinion on what might really ruin Chucks campaign and reputation.
Everyone gave their opinion but Martian's was considered the best. It reads: "I think we should spread false rumours about him indirectly. For example: 'hey ... I heard that Chucks wants to convert every student to be footballers if he's elected President'. Or report a false statement about him to the coach, his denial will cause controversie, and will completely distract him from campaigning further while we help Sam to take advantage of him."
"Nice thought Martians" you replied with a fake smile.
Others follow suit and you've come to an agreement. CONSPIRE AGAINST CHUCKS